← Back to the principles list

Commitment and consistency in ecommerce

Next principle →

A small first yes makes a bigger yes easier.

People like their actions to match what they already said or did. A shopper who orders a $5 swatch box has started acting like someone buying that sofa, so coming back for it can feel like the next step.

Commitment and consistency
Made-up example: a small $5 yes made coming back for the sofa feel like the next step.

Commitment and consistency is the tendency to act in line with what you have already said or done, and its best-known sales use is the foot-in-the-door technique: a small request first, a bigger one later.

In a store, that small request should be useful in its own right, like a sample box, a size finder or a saved item. Keep the path to buying open for anyone who is already sure. The first step should help the shopper decide, even if the answer turns out to be no.

Commitment and consistency example: a $5 swatch box before an $1,800 sofa

One velvet sofa, $1,800, and a visitor who has never touched the fabric. That is a big leap, so only 3 of 1,000 visitors buy it and the store earns $5,400. The owner adds one card next to the sofa: a swatch box with 5 velvet colors for $5. Nothing is discounted or free, and the sofa is still there to buy. Now 220 of 1,000 visitors pick the box and 99 of them come back for the sofa. Boxes and sofas together bring the store $179,300. All of these numbers are made up, and a real store shouldn't expect a jump this big. Give hesitant shoppers a first step that is easy to say yes to and useful in its own right.

How commitment and consistency works with other principles: 4 store examples

These four pairs show what people mistake for commitment and consistency and what helps a small first step lead somewhere. Every store below is made up to show the idea.

Commitment and consistency vs sunk cost effect

Often confused with: Commitment and consistency keeps your actions in line with a stand you took, while the sunk cost effect keeps you going because of what you already spent.

Illustrative store example: A wine club member who checked “I want to explore new regions” keeps ordering to match what she said about herself, and that is commitment and consistency. One who renews a plan she dislikes because she has already spent $400 on it is stuck in sunk cost, so make canceling easy.

Sunk cost effect: why past spending keeps people going →

Commitment and consistency vs reciprocity

Often confused with: A free sample can work through either one: the shopper feels they owe you for a gift, or they asked for it and want to stay in line with that choice.

Illustrative store example: A perfume store drops a free vial in every order, so a shopper who feels she owes the store something is feeling reciprocity. If she asks for the vial and picks the scent herself, consistency joins in, so let her choose before you mention the $90 bottle.

Reciprocity: why a real gift makes shoppers want to give back →

Commitment and consistency and shaping

Works with: Shaping rewards each small step toward a bigger goal, and each step gives the shopper one more thing to stay consistent with.

Illustrative store example: A yarn store moves beginners from a one-evening scarf kit to a hat kit to a $60 sweater kit, and praises each finished photo they share. Each step is small and the shopper starts calling herself a knitter, so keep the kits in that order and don't lead with the sweater.

Shaping: how small rewarded steps lead up to a big purchase →

Commitment and consistency and self-initiated triggers

Works with: Asking for a restock alert is a small stand on wanting the item, so the alert itself reminds the shopper of a choice they already made.

Illustrative store example: A board game store lists a sold-out title with a Notify me button, and a shopper types her email. When the game is back, write “You asked us to tell you” and link straight to that game so she can act on what she already chose.

Self-initiated triggers: why shoppers welcome reminders they asked for →

Put it into practice

How do I pick a small first step for my store?

Look for the biggest doubt behind your biggest purchase. Fabric nobody can feel points to a swatch box. Size worries point to a fit guide. Keep the step cheap or free, and let shoppers choose it themselves, because a step someone picks freely carries more weight than one they were pushed into. Follow up on what they chose, such as showing the sofa in the colors from their box.

When do small steps get in the way?

They get in the way when they slow down someone who is ready, so keep the sofa's own buy button beside the sample. They also turn sour when they trap people, such as a quiz that hides the price until the end or a sample that quietly starts a subscription. Those are tricks, and shoppers remember them. A first step should leave people free to say no.

How is this different from cognitive dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance is the discomfort people feel when their actions and beliefs don't match. Commitment and consistency is the pull to keep your next move in line with your last one, which helps you avoid that discomfort. A shopper who ordered swatches and then buys a rival's sofa may feel a small tug. Dissonance names the tug, and consistency names the pull to stay on course.

How do I check whether a sample box really helped?

Count sofa orders, since box sales alone tell you little. Compare everyone who saw the sample offer with everyone who didn't, and allow time for people to come back, such as 30, 60 and 90 days. Subtract what the boxes cost to pack and ship. Looking only at sample buyers makes the offer look better than it is, because those shoppers were already more interested than most.

Is it the small yes or the sample itself doing the work?

Usually both, and you can't easily separate them. Holding the fabric answers a real worry about color and feel. Having asked for it can also make someone think of themselves as a person choosing a sofa. That mix is good news, because the honest version of this principle is a first step that helps people decide. A sample that leads to a no may have saved you a return.