← Back to the principles list

Hick’s law in ecommerce

Next principle →

More options lead to harder decisions.

When a shopper sees too many choices at once, their brain has to stop and sort them. They ask: Which one is right for me? What is different? Where should I click first? That pause can make a good product feel harder to buy.

Hick's law
Illustrative example: the same 18 teas, reduced from 18 labels to three clear starting groups.

Hick’s law, also called the Hick–Hyman law, is the UX rule behind that pause: the more choices people must compare at one moment, the longer the decision can take.

For an online store, this does not mean “sell fewer products.” It means make the next step obvious. Use clear categories, helpful filters, and plain labels so shoppers know where to start.

Hick’s law example: choosing an evening tea

A store sells 18 teas. A shopper wants a caffeine-free tea for the evening. If all 18 names appear in one flat list, the shopper has to read and guess. If the same teas are grouped into Black tea, Green tea, and Caffeine-free, the shopper knows where to start. The store did not remove products. It made the first decision easier.

How Hick’s law works with other principles: 4 store examples

Hick’s law is about the pause in front of one crowded choice. These pairs show two ideas that get mixed up with it, one that shortens the pause and one that warns against cutting too much. Every store below is made up to show the idea.

Hick’s law vs decision fatigue

Often confused with: Hick’s law is the pause in front of one crowded choice, and decision fatigue is the weaker picking that follows many choices in a row.

Illustrative store example: A gift store shows 40 wrapping papers on one screen, and the long pause there is Hick’s law, so sort them by occasion. A shopper who has already picked the gift, card, ribbon and message may rush past even 4 papers, and that is decision fatigue.

Decision fatigue: why picks get weaker after many choices →

Hick’s law vs Miller’s law

Often confused with: Hick’s law covers how long choosing takes, while Miller’s law covers how much a shopper can hold in memory, so a short menu often gets credited to the wrong one.

Illustrative store example: A garden store cuts its menu to seven links and credits Miller’s law, but the links stay on screen, so the gain is a quicker choice under Hick’s law. Miller’s law applies when a shopper must remember a discount code from one page to enter on the next.

Miller’s law: what shoppers can and can’t hold in memory →

Hick’s law and default bias

Works with: A preselected option gives the shopper a starting answer, so they have less to compare on a page full of choices.

Illustrative store example: Comparing the same kibble in 8 bag sizes slows people down at a dog food store. Preselect the most-bought size so shoppers have a starting point, and keep the other 7 sizes, with their prices, one tap away.

Default bias: why a preselected option so often stays →

Hick’s law vs discoverability

Clashes with: Fewer links speed up the choice, while discoverability needs shoppers to see that a thing exists, so cutting a menu too far can hide the category they came for.

Illustrative store example: To get its menu down to five links, a craft supply store tucks Knitting under More. Knitters can no longer see their category, so keep the links people look for most on view and move the rarely used ones.

Discoverability: how shoppers find out what your store offers →

Put it into practice

How can I apply Hick’s law to my online store?

Pick one common shopper task, such as finding a caffeine-free tea, a gift under $50, or shoes for wide feet. Then make the first step easy to understand. Use names people already know, filters that match real buying questions, and product cards that show the details shoppers compare. Keep search and an “All products” route for people who already know what they want.

Does Hick’s law mean I should sell fewer products?

No. A big catalog can work well if shoppers can quickly find the right part of it. The problem is not “too many products exist.” The problem is “too many choices are dumped on the shopper at the same moment.” Keep useful products. Make the path to the right group clearer.

How is Hick’s law different from choice overload?

They are cousins, not the same thing. Hick’s law is about how long a choice can take when there are more possible responses. Choice overload is the broader idea that too many options can make people feel stuck, delay a decision, or leave. For merchants, the practical lesson is simple: help shoppers narrow the choice before asking them to compare everything.

When can simplifying choices make shopping harder?

Simplifying can hurt when it hides things shoppers need. A quiz can annoy someone who already knows the product name. A tiny menu with vague labels like “Discover” can be harder than a longer menu with clear labels. A clean-looking page is only better if shoppers can still find what they came for.

How can I test whether the change helps?

Give a few people the same task on the old page and the new page. For example: “Find a caffeine-free tea for tonight.” Watch where they click first, where they get confused, whether they finish, and how long it takes. Test on mobile too. This shows whether the page feels clearer, but it does not prove a guaranteed sales lift.