← Back to the principles list

Law of the Instrument in ecommerce

Next principle →

A favorite fix makes every problem look like the same problem.

If your usual answer to a bad month is a discount code, you may reach for it before asking what went wrong. Shoppers may be sending jeans back because they shrink, and a coupon can't change that.

Law of the instrument
Made-up example: asking why points to a different fix than the usual coupon.

The law of the instrument, also called Maslow’s hammer, is the habit of reaching for the tool you know best whatever the problem, as in the saying that to someone with a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

Before you pick a fix, write down why the problem is happening. Return reasons, support emails and reviews will usually give you a start. Then choose whatever fits that reason, even when it's a tool you've never used.

Law of the instrument example: a 20% off code for jeans that shrink

A store's $120 jeans keep getting sent back, so the team reaches for its usual fix: a 20% off code, already tried 9 times. The jeans drop to $96, yet 38 of every 100 pairs still come back, which leaves $5,952 per 100 pairs sold. Then someone asks why. The answer is that the jeans shrink in the wash, so the team adds a shrink guide and keeps the price at $120. With made-up numbers, only 21 of every 100 pairs come back, which leaves $9,480 per 100 pairs sold. A lower price was never going to stop jeans from shrinking.

How the law of the instrument works with other principles: 4 store examples

A favorite fix can pass for common sense, focus or experience. The cards below show where it hides and what keeps it going. Every store below is made up to show the idea.

Law of the instrument vs Occam’s razor

Often confused with: Reusing your one fix can feel like keeping things simple, but Occam’s razor asks for the simplest answer that fits the facts of this problem.

Illustrative store example: A bike parts store owner sends a discount email whenever sales dip and calls it the simple option. If riders are leaving because the size chart doesn't list their wheel, one new line in that chart is the simpler fix.

Occam’s razor: how to pick the simplest answer that fits →

Law of the instrument vs the Pareto principle

Clashes with: The Pareto principle can tempt you to put more behind the few things that work, while the law of the instrument warns that your best tactic may be wrong for the next problem.

Illustrative store example: A hot sauce store gets most of its orders from one email list, so the owner sends more emails. When shoppers start quitting over high shipping costs, another email won't help, so find the reason before you use your strongest channel again.

Pareto principle: how to find the few things that matter →

Law of the instrument and the Dunning-Kruger effect

Works with: The Dunning-Kruger effect, which is debated, says beginners can overrate their skill, so a merchant who has just learned one tactic may think it can fix anything.

Illustrative store example: A yoga mat store owner finishes a short course on email pop-ups and feels ready to solve any store problem with one. A pop-up won't help mats that arrive smelling of rubber, so ask someone with more experience to look at the plan.

Dunning-Kruger effect: why a little knowledge can feel like a lot →

Law of the instrument and confirmation bias

Works with: A favorite tactic keeps its place because you remember the times it worked and forget the times it didn't.

Illustrative store example: A soap store owner is sure a free gift always helps, because she remembers the two months it went well. List every time the offer ran, good months and bad, before you use it again.

Confirmation bias: why a favorite tactic keeps looking right →

Put it into practice

How do I stop reaching for the same fix every time?

Make one rule: nobody picks a fix until the reason for the problem is written down. Read return notes, support emails and reviews about that product, and watch a few shopper visits if you can. Then list two or three possible fixes, including one you've never tried. Seeing them side by side makes it easier to notice when you're choosing out of habit.

When does avoiding your favorite fix go too far?

When you chase something new just to feel thorough. A hammer is still the right tool for a nail, so if a discount cleared old stock last year and you have old stock again, use it. Weeks spent hunting for a clever answer to a plain problem cost money too. The trouble starts when you pick the tool first and look for the reason afterwards.

How is the law of the instrument different from confirmation bias?

The law of the instrument affects which fix you reach for. Confirmation bias affects how you judge that fix afterwards, by noticing the wins and forgetting the misses. They feed each other: you keep using the coupon, you remember the good months, and the coupon starts to look like the answer to everything. A plain list of every time you used it helps with both.

How do I compare a new fix with the old one?

Measure the problem you set out to fix, in money as well as orders. For jeans that come back, count returned pairs and what you keep after returns, since a coupon can bring more orders while the returns carry on. With enough shoppers, you can A/B test the two fixes by showing each version to half of them. Otherwise, compare similar weeks before and after.

Why are discount codes such an easy trap?

A code takes minutes to set up and orders often come in the same day, so it feels like it worked. Some of those buyers would have paid full price anyway, and whatever caused the problem is still there. Repeat it often enough and shoppers can learn to wait for the next code. Before your next one, ask what you would try if discounts weren't allowed.