← Back to the principles list

Mental models in ecommerce

Next principle →

Shoppers expect your store to work like every other store they use.

People learn how to shop from every store they've used, so they reach for the cart in the top corner and expect the logo to go home. Move those things and they can feel lost, even on a beautiful page.

Mental models
Made-up example: the cart works best in the spot where shoppers already look.

A mental model is the picture in a shopper's head of how something works, built from past experience, which is why most people look for the cart in the top-right corner.

Keep the parts shoppers use without thinking in the places they expect: cart, search, menu and product photos. Put your personality into color, words and photography. When you must do something unusual, explain it on the page.

Mental model example: moving the cart back to the top corner for a $120 lamp

After adding a $120 table lamp to the cart, a shopper on a phone goes straight to the top-right corner, where most stores keep the cart. This store's corner is empty, because its cart icon sits in the footer at the bottom left. All made up, but say 5 of 10 shoppers buy the lamp, for $600. The owner moves the same icon, same size and color, back to the top-right corner. Buyers rise to 7 of 10, and the lamp now earns the store $840. Put the basics where shoppers already look for them.

How a mental model works with other principles: 4 store examples

What shoppers expect shapes how they read almost everything in a store. These pairs separate it from two similar biases and show two places where it helps. Every store below is made up to show the idea.

Mental model vs familiarity bias

Often confused with: A mental model is what shoppers expect a store to do, while familiarity bias is their preference for what they already know.

Illustrative store example: A running shoe store keeps its checkout button where shoppers expect it, so they find it without thinking, which is a mental model at work. If those shoppers trust the page more because it shows a payment app they already use, that is familiarity bias.

Familiarity bias: why shoppers lean toward what they know →

Mental model vs expectations bias

Often confused with: A mental model predicts how a store will behave, while expectations bias changes how a product tastes, looks or feels once the shopper has it.

Illustrative store example: A shopper assumes a coffee store's account page will let them pause a subscription, and that is a mental model. The same shopper finding a $30 bag richer because the label promised rich flavor is showing expectations bias.

Expectations bias: how promises change how a product feels →

Mental model and provide exit points

Works with: A mental model tells shoppers what Back and an x should do, so a way out helps only if it works the way they picture it.

Illustrative store example: A kids' clothing store opens its size guide in a full-screen window, and the phone's Back button throws shoppers off the product page. They expected Back to close the window, so make it do exactly that.

Provide exit points: how to let shoppers leave without losing them →

Mental model and skeuomorphism

Works with: Skeuomorphism borrows the look of real objects, and that helps because a cart icon taps into what shoppers already know about shopping.

Illustrative store example: A baking supply store swaps its cart icon for a tiny whisk to match the brand, and shoppers no longer know where their items went. Keep a cart or bag shape, since people know what those hold, and bring in the brand with color.

Skeuomorphism: why real-world shapes need no explanation →

Put it into practice

How do I use mental models when I redesign my store?

List what shoppers do without thinking: find the cart, search, open the menu, go home with the logo. Keep those where other stores keep them. On a phone, that includes swiping photos sideways and tapping outside a drawer to close it. Spend your creativity on color, words and photos, and try changing how a control looks before you move it.

When should I break what shoppers expect?

Break it only with a clear reason, and show the new way on the page. Following habits can also backfire when a habit misleads. A pre-order button that looks like a normal Add to Cart can make shoppers assume it ships right away, so state the ship date. Copying the odd choices of a big store is risky too, since people already know how that store works.

How is a mental model different from Jakob’s law?

Jakob’s law, named after usability expert Jakob Nielsen, says people spend most of their time on other sites, so they expect yours to work the same way. That explains where much of a shopper's mental model comes from. A mental model is the broader idea, because it also covers what people expect from physical shops and from the product itself.

Do all my shoppers share the same mental model?

No. A regular customer has learned your store, while a first-time visitor brings habits from everywhere else. Buyers for a business may expect bulk pricing and invoices. Shoppers in other countries may expect different sizes, date formats and payment methods. Work out who your main shoppers are and where else they buy, because that's the store they're comparing you to.

How can I spot a mental model problem on my store?

Ask a handful of people to do one simple task, such as “Find this lamp and check out,” and watch their first move. A wrong first tap tells you what they expected. Then watch replays of real visits for dead clicks, which are taps on something that does nothing, such as an empty corner. After a fix, you should see fewer of them.