Variable Reward in ecommerce
Next principle →A reward shoppers can't predict can feel more exciting than a known one.
When shoppers know a free gift is a rose serum, they can decide they don't need it. Keep the gift a secret and they may want to find out, as long as every gift is worth having.
A variable reward is a reward people can't fully predict, such as a mystery gift, and when the unknown part is the timing it's called intermittent reinforcement.
In a store, this might be a secret gift at a spending goal or a surprise tucked into some orders. Make every outcome real and worth having. A rigged prize wheel is a trick, so leave it out.
Variable reward example: a mystery serum instead of a named one at $75
A shopper at a made-up beauty store has $64 in the cart. A free gift comes at $75, so they can pay now or add a $14 face mask and get the gift. When the store names the gift upfront as a rose serum, shoppers can weigh it up, and most pay the $64. The owner keeps the same gift but calls it a free mystery serum in a closed box. Most shoppers now add the mask, for a $78 order. A small unknown can make a real gift harder to pass up.
How variable reward works with other principles: 4 store examples
A reward people can't predict sits close to other ideas about surprise and habit. Two of these pairs are often mistaken for a variable reward and two show how it can keep shoppers coming back. Every store below is made up to show the idea.
Variable reward vs delighters
Often confused with: A delighter is a one-off surprise nobody expected, while a variable reward is an uncertain prize that shoppers learn to look forward to.
Illustrative store example: A sock subscription slips a small free keyring into one box without warning, and that is a delighter. Once its page promises a different surprise in every box, subscribers start to look forward to it, and it has become a variable reward.
Delighters: how small surprises get customers talking →Variable reward vs curiosity gap
Often confused with: Both play on not knowing, but a curiosity gap holds back a piece of information, while a variable reward leaves the prize uncertain.
Illustrative store example: A bookstore headline reading “The ending readers still argue about” makes shoppers click to find out, which is a curiosity gap. A free bookmark in a surprise design with every order is a variable reward, because the unknown part is the prize.
Curiosity gap: why an unanswered question makes shoppers click →Variable reward and investment loops
Works with: An investment loop means shoppers save details that build up, such as a wish list, and an uncertain reward gives them a reason to come back to it.
Illustrative store example: A vinyl record store lets shoppers build a wish list, then picks one saved record each Friday for a surprise $5 off. The list is the effort and the pick is the surprise, so keep the normal price honest and the discount real.
Investment loops: why saved effort keeps shoppers coming back →Variable reward and internal trigger
Works with: An internal trigger is a feeling, such as boredom, that sends someone to your store, and an uncertain reward can turn that visit into a habit.
Illustrative store example: A gadget store posts one surprise deal a day, and bored shoppers start checking it on their lunch break. Keep every deal real and let people turn off the daily email, because a habit built on boredom can lead them to buy things they don't need.
Internal trigger: how a feeling sends shoppers back to you →Put it into practice
How do I use variable rewards without tricking shoppers?
Make every possible outcome worth having and say so plainly, as in “Every order gets a full-size sample.” If only some orders get a prize, say that too. Never rig a wheel to land near the big prize, and never give a gift a made-up value. For skincare or food, list what the gift might contain, so nobody gets a surprise they can't use.
What makes a good mystery gift?
Pick something most of your shoppers would be glad to get, such as a travel-size favorite, a seasonal sample or a small accessory. It helps if the gift shows off another product line. Tell shoppers the type of item and keep the detail secret. “Mystery serum” gives them enough to want it while leaving something to find out.
When do surprise rewards backfire?
They backfire when the reveal disappoints. A shopper who spends extra for a mystery gift and finds a tiny packet can feel cheated. Flashy spin wheels can also look out of place in a calm, premium store, and some shoppers simply prefer to know what they're getting. Prizes that only some buyers win can count as a lottery in many places, so check the rules before you run one.
How is a variable reward different from a normal loyalty reward?
A normal loyalty reward is fixed: buy ten bags, get one free. Shoppers can count toward it, which makes it a clear and fair deal. A variable reward leaves something unknown, such as what the gift will be or which order it arrives in. Fixed rewards feel dependable and variable ones can feel more exciting, and plenty of stores use both.
How do I compare a mystery gift with a plain discount?
Show half of your shoppers the gift and half the discount, and make both cost you about the same. Compare order size and what you keep after the cost of each. Then look further out: how many gift shoppers return items, complain or buy again. A reward that only pulls people in once may not be worth repeating.