Backfire Effect in ecommerce
Next principle →Telling shoppers they are wrong can make them hold on tighter.
A shopper who loves cotton sheets may hear “cotton is wrong” as an attack on them. Give the same fact without the insult and they have room to change their mind.
The backfire effect is the idea that correcting a firmly held belief can sometimes make a person hold that belief more strongly, though it is debated and now looks much rarer than people once thought.
So keep correcting wrong ideas about your products, because clear facts usually help. Aim them at the product and leave the shopper's past choices out of it. Respect what they already own, then say what yours does differently.
Backfire effect example: “Wrong choice” or “Classic choice” on a sheets page
In our made-up store, a shopper is choosing between cotton sheets at $90 and eucalyptus sheets at $150. The page heading says: “Cotton? Wrong choice. Eucalyptus sleeps cooler.” To someone who has slept on cotton for years, that reads like an insult, so they defend it. Most shoppers stick with cotton, and that's $90 an order. The store then changes one word: “Cotton? Classic choice. Eucalyptus sleeps cooler.” The claim about eucalyptus stays, but the insult is gone. Now eucalyptus outsells cotton, at $150 an order. Say what is better about your product without telling shoppers they were wrong.
How the backfire effect works with other principles: 4 store examples
Digging in after a correction gets blamed on many causes. Two of these pairs separate lookalikes and two show what can make a shopper dig in harder. Every store below is made up to show the idea.
Backfire effect vs reactance
Often confused with: Reactance is pushing back because someone seems to limit your freedom to choose, while the backfire effect is a belief growing stronger after someone corrects it.
Illustrative store example: A cookware store writes “Nonstick coatings wear out in a few years,” and a shopper who swears by nonstick grows even more sure it is best, which is the backfire effect. A pop-up saying “You must decide today” is different: the shopper objects to being told what to do, and that is reactance.
Reactance: why pressure makes shoppers push back →Backfire effect vs Streisand effect
Often confused with: Both make things worse through an attempted fix, but the backfire effect comes from correcting a belief and the Streisand effect comes from trying to hide information.
Illustrative store example: A skincare store deletes a review about a rash, and screenshots of it spread far beyond the review page, which is the Streisand effect. Telling that same customer “You used it wrong” risks the backfire effect, so reply politely with the ingredients and a refund.
Streisand effect: why hiding a review can draw more eyes to it →Backfire effect and confirmation bias
Works with: A shopper with confirmation bias looks for proof of what they already think, so a blunt correction can send them hunting for reasons to stay put.
Illustrative store example: A shopper who thinks vegan leather peels reads a bag store's line “Our vegan leather never peels” and goes looking for the one review that says it did. State only what you can back up, such as the material and the warranty, and answer that review in public.
Confirmation bias: why shoppers notice what fits their view →Backfire effect and self-serving bias
Works with: Self-serving bias makes people blame outside causes when things go wrong, so correcting their version of events can harden the belief that the store is at fault.
Illustrative store example: A knitwear store tells a customer her sweater shrank because she washed it wrong, and she grows surer the sweater was the problem. Put washing steps on the product page, then answer with a fix before discussing whose fault it was.
Self-serving bias: why people credit themselves and blame the tool →Put it into practice
How do I correct a wrong idea about my product without starting a fight?
Start with what is true about their current choice, then add the one fact you want them to know. “Cast iron is great. This pan is lighter, so you can lift it with one hand” respects what they own. Avoid “wrong,” “myth” and “stop buying.” Keep claims to what you can show, such as a weight, a wash test or a clear photo.
Is the backfire effect real?
Possibly, but it is debated and looks far rarer than its reputation. It has been hard to repeat, and most people shift at least a little when they get a clear correction. People worry about it most with beliefs tied to who someone is, such as politics or health. The sheets story is made up and more dramatic than real life usually is. So don't stay silent out of fear. A wrong idea about your product usually deserves a plain, polite correction.
Can being too gentle go wrong?
Yes. If you soften a message so much that shoppers can't tell what you are claiming, nothing gets corrected. Some wrong ideas need a direct answer, such as whether a product is safe for a baby or works with a given charger. Say the fact plainly and early, then explain. Good manners should shape your tone and never hide what is true.
How is the backfire effect different from a shopper who just isn't convinced?
A shopper who stays put after a correction hasn't been persuaded, and that is common and harmless. The backfire effect would mean they end up more certain than before. You can rarely tell the two apart from orders alone, and you often don't need to. Either way, the next step is a better reason, told more kindly.
What shows that softer wording worked?
Change one line, as in the sheets example, and show each version to a similar group of shoppers at the same time. Compare which product they choose and what they spend per order. Then read support messages and ad comments for signs of people arguing. If the new wording brings calmer questions and more orders of the product you pitched, keep it.