Streisand Effect in ecommerce
Next principle →Trying to hide a bad review can lead more people to see it.
Delete a 2-star review and the person who wrote it may notice, share a screenshot and tell everyone you removed it. Leave it up and answer it, and it usually stays one review on one page.
The Streisand effect is when trying to hide, remove or censor something makes far more people see it than would have seen it otherwise.
It's named after singer Barbra Streisand, whose legal fight over a photo of her home sent far more people to look at it. For a store, the lesson is to leave honest complaints up and answer them. Deleting one can give people a second story to share.
Streisand effect example: a deleted 2-star review about $60 leggings
A store sells leggings for $60, and one buyer leaves a 2-star review: “Waistband runs tight.” Suppose the owner deletes it, leaving only praise like “Love the fabric.” In this made-up story, the buyer notices and posts about it, 800,000 people see the deleted review and the week brings in $600. Now suppose the owner keeps the review on the page. Only store visitors see it, and the week brings in $2,400. Real cases can go either way, but deleting is what gave a small complaint a bigger audience.
How the Streisand effect works with other principles: 4 store examples
A removal can set off more than one reaction. These pairs show who goes looking, what spreads next, what people mistake it for and the goal that tempts a store to delete. Every store below is made up to show the idea.
Streisand effect vs backfire effect
Often confused with: The Streisand effect is hiding something and making it spread, while the backfire effect is correcting someone and hardening their belief, an effect that may be rare.
Illustrative store example: A camping gear store removes a comment on its own page saying its tent poles snap, and more people go looking for it, which is the Streisand effect. A long correction that only leaves that customer surer of the problem is the backfire effect, so leave the comment up and answer once, calmly.
Backfire effect: why correcting someone can harden their belief →Streisand effect and reactance
Works with: Hiding reviews threatens a shopper's freedom to see them, and that feeling can add to the urge to go looking.
Illustrative store example: A meal kit store turns reviews off after a run of complaints about small portions. Shoppers who can't read them can feel shut out and go asking elsewhere, so turn reviews back on and show exact portion sizes on the page.
Reactance: why shoppers want what they're told they can't have →Streisand effect and the second-order effect
Works with: The direct aim is removing one bad review, while the later result may be a long thread about the removal.
Illustrative store example: A headphone store sends a legal letter asking a blogger to take down one bad review, and the review does come down. The next result may be a bigger post about the letter, so ask what could happen after that before you send anything.
Second-order effect: how one fix can cause the next problem →Put it into practice
Does removing something always make it spread?
No. Many removals go unnoticed, and plenty of bad reviews stay obscure whether they're deleted or not. The effect tends to show up when the person has an audience, the removal looks unfair or the story makes people angry. That doesn't make deleting safe. You can't tell ahead of time which removal will catch fire, and hiding honest reviews misleads shoppers either way.
How is the Streisand effect different from ordinary bad press?
Ordinary bad press starts with the problem itself, such as a faulty batch or a late delivery. The Streisand effect starts with the attempt to hide it. A tight waistband is a small complaint that few people would ever hear about, and a deletion can turn it into news. That's good for you in one way: you can avoid this kind of trouble simply by leaving the review alone.
Can deleting reviews get my store in legal trouble?
It can. In the United States, Federal Trade Commission rules ban presenting the reviews on your site as all or most of what you received when you've hidden some for being negative. Removing spam, fakes or abuse is generally allowed if the same rules apply to good and bad reviews. Other countries have their own rules, so ask a lawyer about yours. This is general information and isn't legal advice.
How do I check whether keeping bad reviews is working?
Watch a few things for a few weeks after you stop deleting: how many shoppers add the product to their cart, returns and what people ask support. Search your store name now and then to see whether complaints are showing up elsewhere. Keeping a bad review won't fix everything, but if orders hold steady and complaints stay on your own page, it's doing its job.