Cognitive load in ecommerce
Next principle →Extra mental effort makes shopping feel like work.
When buying is easy, shoppers pick a size and move on. When a page makes them do math, guess at a label or fill in extra boxes, they get tired and some of them leave.
Cognitive load, sometimes called mental friction when a page causes it, is the amount of thinking a task asks of a person at one moment.
Some thinking belongs to the purchase, such as deciding if a frame suits the photo. The rest comes from your page: sums, unclear labels and hard forms. Take that second kind away and shoppers can spend their attention on the product.
Cognitive load example: a frame page that makes shoppers do the math
A store sells a frame with a border for $60. To order, a shopper has to work out the frame size: photo size plus 5 inches, typed into two empty boxes. Shoppers stop to do the math, and most leave. The conversion rate, the share of visitors who buy, is 6%. The owner changes the question to “Your photo size” with three buttons: 5x7, 8x10 and 11x14. The store does the math, and the page confirms that the frame fits. With these made-up numbers, the conversion rate rises to 14%. The frame and the price stayed the same, and the thinking moved from the shopper to the store.
How cognitive load works with other principles: 4 store examples
Cognitive load is about how much thinking a step asks for, and people often mix it up with fatigue or memory limits. These four pairs sort that out and show two ways to cut the effort. Every store below is made up to show the idea.
Cognitive load vs decision fatigue
Often confused with: Cognitive load is how much thinking one step asks for, while decision fatigue, a more debated idea, is choices getting worse after many steps.
Illustrative store example: A custom suit store asks for chest size using a confusing chart, and that one hard step is cognitive load. After 15 choices of lapels, linings and buttons, the shopper starts picking anything, which looks like decision fatigue, so offer a few ready-made sets.
Decision fatigue: why choices can get worse after many steps →Cognitive load vs Miller's law
Often confused with: Miller's law is one limit on how much people can keep in mind, while cognitive load covers all the mental effort a task asks for.
Illustrative store example: A phone case store makes shoppers carry a model code from one page to the next, which strains the memory limit Miller's law describes. Hard-to-read type and a confusing menu add cognitive load without asking them to remember anything, so fix those and show the code on both pages.
Miller's law: why people can keep only a few things in mind →Cognitive load and Tesler's law
Works with: Tesler's law says some complexity can't be removed, only moved, so when the store does the tax and shipping math the shopper has less to think about.
Illustrative store example: A wine store asks shoppers to look up their state's tax and add shipping themselves. That math can't vanish, so move it to the store's side and show one total once the shopper types a ZIP code.
Tesler's law: who should carry the hard parts of buying →Cognitive load and chunking
Works with: Chunking can lower cognitive load by grouping the same information so it takes less effort to read and check.
Illustrative store example: A guitar store's checkout shows the card number as one run of 16 digits, so a shopper checking for typos has to count along the whole line. Add a space after every four digits as they type, which keeps the same digits and makes them easier to check.
Chunking: how small groups make long lists easier to read →Put it into practice
Where should I look for extra mental effort on my store?
Start where shoppers have to stop and work something out. Common spots are sizes given in codes such as “BLK-XL-V2”, totals that appear only at the end, sums of any kind and address forms that don't fill themselves in. Then ask who could do this work instead of the shopper. Usually your store can.
What are intrinsic and extraneous load?
Intrinsic load is the thinking a task needs by its nature, such as deciding which frame suits a photo. Extraneous load is the extra thinking your page adds, such as a confusing size box. Remove the extraneous kind wherever you can. Some intrinsic load should stay, because that thinking is the shopper choosing well.
Can I make a page too simple?
Yes. Cutting sizes, materials or washing instructions for a cleaner look leaves shoppers guessing, and guessing is hard work too. Some shoppers also want the detail, such as exact frame dimensions. Keep the facts they need and make them easy to find. Presets should leave room for unusual sizes as well, so include a custom option.
How is cognitive load different from choice overload?
Choice overload is one source of cognitive load: too many options at once can leave shoppers stuck. Cognitive load is wider. A page with two options can still be tiring if it uses odd words or makes shoppers do sums. So trimming options won't always help. Look for what else the page is asking them to think about.
How can I measure whether a page got easier?
Watch three or four people try it on a phone. Note where they pause, go back or make mistakes, and how long the task takes. Then ask how hard it felt on a scale from 1 to 7. Then try both versions on live traffic, with visitors split at random, to see whether more of them finish.